When does land-use opposition stop a proposal instead of converting into concessions?
Gowanus Neighborhood Rezoning
The Gowanus case should be framed as a mixed case, not a simple loss or win. Anti-rezoning opponents failed to stop approval and lost their lawsuit, but justice-oriented coalitions appear to have helped lock in measurable public commitments, especially NYCHA repair funding and sewer/environmental conditions. The continuing dispute over Public Place/Gowanus Green makes this case central for the atlas because it shows how environmental risk, affordable housing, and public housing needs can collide.
Industry City / Sunset Park Rezoning Withdrawal
Industry City is a strong successful blocking campaign. The applicant withdrew after sustained community opposition and after the local Council Member said he would vote no. The case is especially useful because the campaign did not only say 'no'; groups like UPROSE and Protect Sunset Park advanced a green industrial waterfront vision as an alternative.