Atlas

Tactic Guide

Use this page to understand when a tactic had leverage, where it was mostly symbolic, and which case records support that judgment.

High-leverage pattern

Councilmember alignment + coalition pressure

Most decisive observed pattern in this seed dataset.

Conditions

Project is in ULURP/Council stage; local councilmember opposes; broader elected coalition reinforces; developer depends on discretionary approval.

Risks

Can be vulnerable to changing Council norms or citywide backlash against member deference.

Pattern Cards

Use these as diagnostic prompts, not recipes. The same tactic can behave differently when approval stage, local elected alignment, or legal posture changes.

Effectiveness: Low To Medium

Litigation after approval

Conditions

Can delay or produce temporary wins; stronger if paired with political leverage or alternate implementation plan.

Risks

Appeals often reverse trial wins; courts defer to agency environmental review in many cases.

Gowanus Neighborhood Rezoning Inwood Rezoning and Northern Manhattan Is Not For Sale Litigation East Side Coastal Resiliency / East River Park oppositionElizabeth Street Garden vs. Haven Green affordable senior housing
Effectiveness: Medium

Environmental justice / public health reframing

Conditions

Strongest when tied to funding eligibility, federal programs, racial/economic justice narratives, and clear design alternatives.

Risks

May be absorbed into official language without changing core project.

BQE Central / BQE Environmental Justice corridor campaignIndustry City / Sunset Park Rezoning Withdrawal Resilient Edgemere / post-Sandy recovery, rezoning, and managed retreat concerns
Effectiveness: Low For Stopping; Medium For Media

Direct action at construction stage

Conditions

Project is already approved and under construction.

Risks

Legal/policing risk; may not change agency behavior if courts and funding are already aligned.

East Side Coastal Resiliency / East River Park opposition
Effectiveness: Medium To High

Alternative-site or alternative-policy proposal

Conditions

Advocates provide a credible alternative that satisfies part of the government's stated objective.

Risks

Alternative may require new approvals, funding, or land control; opponents may challenge feasibility.

Elizabeth Street Garden vs. Haven Green affordable senior housingIndustry City / Sunset Park Rezoning Withdrawal